Cherylee Black, Can NDEs Lead to Psychokinesis? |548|

Not an Egely wheel, but a pinwheel in a vaccumn experiment at about 1:25:12

Interesting, but inconclusive. I have a video from an old series somewhere that is actually better than all of the ones I've seen on YouTube so far. I don't know that some sort of PSI is the causal agent for the effect produced. Maybe it is. Or maybe it's something else.

If PK was a thing, it should be far more self-evident across a far larger cross-section of the population. But instead, it's always in this gray area, as if whatever is behind the phenomenon wants us to question it without giving us definitive proof. This pattern also fits the UFO phenomenon, so I think it's fair to ask if the two are linked. What if the aliens like messing with our minds just to see what we'll make of it?
 
thx. fav line:

Ancient and aboriginal cultures have spent as much time and energy developing techniques of inducing such states as we do trying develop ways of suppressing them
Agreed! And then of course we have the efforts of SCIENTISTS to suppress, ignore, et al. I

I was just reading Silver Birch, an extremely high spirit (the most recent such sage / his medium died in the 1960s) talking about unevolved souls coming to the afterworld in droves and needing remedial education.. More on that soon.
 
Okay — I'm jumping in on this one. First we need some sort of clear definition as to what we mean by "The Moral Imperative". Are we going with the Kantian Moral Philosophy – the idea that it's part of his set of categorical imperatives? If so, then we're taking the view that morality is bounded by Kant's view of pure reason — the idea that the moral principle in question is a law of nature and therefore universal. Then, if we can will ourselves to act on what we recognize as that law, we can be said to be acting morally. Or are we looking at it as some other concept? If so, what exactly?

I'm proposing that the moral imperative is individualistic. Meaning every individual is supposed to do based on who they are.
That Bad Doers are supposed to do bad.
I'm arguing that the mistake is for Good Doers to assume that the principles which govern both good and bad deeds are moral. They(Principles) might be universal, and moral, but maybe not universally-moral.

For instance: A president of a country or large corporation can make a moral judgement call which result in the immediate death of 1000's of innocent lives. If the moral principle is universal, then that would be 1000x more evil than me killing one single innocent person... So if I kill an innocent person today, am i morally justified to say, "well 999 to go before Im as evil as the president was today"?
 
Last edited:
I'm proposing that the moral imperative is individualistic. Meaning every individual is supposed to do based on who they are.
That Bad Doers are supposed to do bad.
I'm arguing that the mistake is for Good Doers to assume that the principles which govern both good and bad deeds are moral. They(Principles) might be universal, and moral, but maybe not universally-moral.

For instance: A president of a country or large corporation can make a moral judgement call which result in the immediate death of 1000's of innocent lives. If the moral principle is universal, then that would be 1000x more evil than me killing one single innocent person... So if I kill an innocent person today, am i morally justified to say, "well 999 to go before Im as evil as the president was today"?

Okay — Still waiting for @Alex to chime in.

In the meantime, I get your perspective. The way it's framed, it's self-coherent, but it's very different that the academic Kantian interpretation. Because of its individualistic nature, I wonder how useful it is other than to justify one's own actions. It would seem to leave the door open for hypocrisy — one day the individual decides X is moral, the next day the individual decides X is immoral, depending on whether or not it suits their needs.

Personally, I'd have to say that without some sort of universal moral compass points, concepts of morality are meaningless. Yet most of us have some sense of fairness, and we don't see hypocrisy as acceptable moral behavior ( regardless of the framework ). In other words, in an individualistic framework, the "bad doer" cannot suddenly become a hypocrite and become a "good doer" without violating the same moral principle as the "good doer" becoming a hypocrite and becoming a "bad doer". This implies some higher ( perhaps universal ) principle that embodies both concepts.

I contend, that the higher principle has to do with the concept of truth, and that truth is not individualistic. It stands apart from our subjective interpretations. That's why we have such things as trials to establish guilt, and by extension whether or not some moral crime has been committed. If the subjective "truth" of the accused is all we needed, we wouldn't need a justice system. The driver who runs a red light believing it to have been green according to "their truth" would take precedence over the objective evidence of the red light camera.
 
Last edited:
Okay — Still waiting for @Alex to chime in.

In the meantime, I get your perspective. The way it's framed, it's self-coherent, but it's very different that the academic Kantian interpretation. Because of its individualistic nature, I wonder how useful it is other than to justify one's own actions. It would seem to leave the door open for hypocrisy — one day the individual decides X is moral, the next day the individual decides X is immoral, depending on whether or not it suits their needs.

Personally, I'd have to say that without some sort of universal moral compass points, concepts of morality are meaningless. Yet most of us have some sense of fairness, and we don't see hypocrisy as acceptable moral behavior ( regardless of the framework ). In other words, in an individualistic framework, the "bad doer" cannot suddenly become a hypocrite and become a "good doer" without violating the same moral principle as the "good doer" becoming a hypocrite and becoming a "bad doer". This implies some higher ( perhaps universal ) principle that embodies both concepts.

I contend, that the higher principle has to do with the concept of truth, and that truth is not individualistic. It stands apart from our subjective interpretations. That's why we have such things as trials to establish guilt, and by extension whether or not some moral crime has been committed. If the subjective "truth" of the accused is all we needed, we wouldn't need a justice system. The driver who runs a red light believing it to have been green according to "their truth" would take precedence over the objective evidence of the red light camera.
Perfect.

Moral justification is separate from social justification. But both are taken into consideration by any judicial system.

5,000 years ago if you have a civilization rampant with rape and theft, it might be the correct moral move to institute castration and cutting off hands of offenders, only because you don't have a police or prison system in place, nor time to wait until one is created, and if you don't institute the drastic measures, your civilization may be subject to collapse. So you might justify cutting off a mens hands for stealing a loaves of bread, in order to secure the rule of law for that civilization. Then, as that society grows and builds governance systems it's collective moral imperative will lead them to dial back punishments to whatever deterrent is needed, I.E, maybe once you have a few full time police officers patrolling you only need to cut of a finger now to deter theft. This could be called a universal moral imperative(because it's universal, moral, and imperative), but it's not a set of rules that apply universally.... That(set of rules that apply universally) would be need to be a social construct, as it's structuring style seems to always depend on the subjects to which it need to be applied.
 
Perfect.

Moral justification is separate from social justification. But both are taken into consideration by any judicial system.

5,000 years ago if you have a civilization rampant with rape and theft, it might be the correct moral move to institute castration and cutting off hands of offenders, only because you don't have a police or prison system in place, nor time to wait until one is created, and if you don't institute the drastic measures, your civilization may be subject to collapse. So you might justify cutting off a mens hands for stealing a loaves of bread, in order to secure the rule of law for that civilization. Then, as that society grows and builds governance systems it's collective moral imperative will lead them to dial back punishments to whatever deterrent is needed, I.E, maybe once you have a few full time police officers patrolling you only need to cut of a finger now to deter theft. This could be called a universal moral imperative(because it's universal, moral, and imperative), but it's not a set of rules that apply universally.... That(set of rules that apply universally) would be need to be a social construct, as it's structuring style seems to always depend on the subjects to which it need to be applied.

Interesting. I have always believed that the punishment needs to be commensurate with the crime, but never considered the sort of situation you describe, where there is no larger justice system to implement things such as fines or jail time. However, I would still argue that excess punishment is still immoral, even if it prevents further crimes. My reasoning goes back to the classic trolley problem — the rationale behind utilitarianism. We cannot allow ourselves to be fooled by the numbers. Sacrificing fairness for the good of the many just puts the many under the rule of tyranny.
 
Maybe Hitler needs to reincarnate as a porn shop janitor in west Hollywood in order to burn away specific karma or ego.

I had a dream about this exact subject years ago. Here it is, from my journal, dated 8/6/1990:

> [3:23 am] I am going to start w/ the last scene first, because it may be the most interesting. It concerns Adolf Hitler most specifically. I see him having recently died for at least the second time this century, w/ full military honors, in the person of a Russian military commander. His name began with the sound "enh"(first or last I do not know--probably first name + letter "N" in our alphabet). After dying as Hitler, he had come all the way to Russia, where he was duly born + had to undertake the difficulties of a new language (which he enjoyed). In fact, he seemed very happy to be able to have this chance to do good things. His tenure later in the Soviet military was not characterized by cruelty, though efficiency was one of his hallmarks. He was an officer of mid-rank. This was exactly where he wanted to be because he didn't want to have the opportunity or ability to cause the kind of harm he caused in his previous life.

He allowed some bad things to happen but would make an effort to mitigate the damage when he was in a position to do so. For instance, if he was asked to do something that would lead to 20 casualties, he would (if possible) modify the way he carried out the orders so that there were 17 casualties instead. He didn't seem conscious that he did those things for the reasons he did them. To everyone else, he just looked "practical". If 20 casualties cost the government 20,000 rubles but 17 casualties cost 10,000 rubles, he'd say they couldn't waste money on an operation that would send the same message whether 17 or 20 casualties.

I then see a Soviet funeral service. Immediately afterward, I see the image of an exploded building with Hitler's body somewhere inside. Standing along two sides of the path leading to this building are a great many people, formerly having been subjected to Hitler, now humorously paying homage to him [paying their respects]. They keep looking up and I see a shadow on the ground from above, so perhaps a plane?

When Hitler originally came into Russia, it was on foot in the snow and he wasn't aware of the passing of his physical body. He was in the house where he was found when he saw (as a ghost) Russian soldiers flood the building. He was afraid they would recognize him, so he made an effort to hide. He thought they didn't notice him. He reasoned this was because they hadn't looked closely at his uniform and thought he was one of them. In fact, they didn't see him at all. After playing cat and mouse while the soldiers searched the building, Hitler realized he could walk among them safely. He did this (in his mind) because they seemed to be looking everywhere else except within their midst. His fear of them was so great that he stayed with them, one soldier in particular.

The man Hitler attached himself to belonged to a group of Russian soldiers. When they returned to Russia from the front, Hitler went with them. He was surprised they allowed him to stay, and even more, that they didn't recognize him. Next, he was born into that one soldier's family and then later went into the Russian military himself.
 
I had a dream ...

Such dreams just prove how powerful the mind is at creating such realistic imagery — though completely fictional. Still, the correlation between some dreams and real-world events is too uncanny to ignore. Something else is going on sometimes, even if we don't know for sure what it is.
 
Last edited:
(Warning...Writing in the middle of my next Master's class but it's the only place I have at this time)

Listening to the latest guest has gotten me inspired again to engage with some "alternatives".
As a Canadian, who has been brought up in the "peace, order, and good government" and who had a lifetime of recognizing our good neighbour to the south with "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" I am once again reminded of Alex's bias into the way he's seeing the world and the extended consciousness world.
Not that I don't have my own bias, and I'm aware of that. We're all aware and unaware of our biases and I think only in recognizing that like the great immeasurable jigsaw puzzle of existence, we have portions and are missing great portions. Alex (and everyone here) has ways of seeing corner pieces and middle pieces, and obscure and obvious pieces that I can't see and vice versa. That's the benefit of Skeptiko for me. When it works, we can put aside ego and our insistence of WHAT THINGS ARE and imagine beyond what we see, think or experience for the truth- or our version of it.

Okay, preamble out of the way. Let me say that whenever Alex says, "Look there are only a few options here you are either a... "and the listing of various armed camps on a particular subject about the nature of reality comes up.
But, the reality is, that we're insects in the understanding of the main nature of the universe.
It's always baffling to me because we're insects that people can speak with such authority on such things.

Imagine a thought experiment of conscious ants. They would tell you that there are the mounders, the grasslanders, and the stone folk. The mounders stay close to the ant mount. For them life is about family, and structure. The anthill is everything, and existence is designed strictly to build the mount to encompass all things. Grasslanders are those who roam the endless lands It goes on forever. No one can see beyond the fronds of grass in front of them, but you can be sure that the grasses go on forever. You have faith that everything is in the grass- food, pockets of water, and each other. We are all connected in the vine. It doesn't matter how far you are from the mound. The anthill is part of the inter-web of grasses. The stone folk begin at the great slab and to the massive monument just up the ziggurat (steps) of the wise ones. The titans that walk past us are ignorant of who we are. If you are very quiet by the stone, you can learn the secrets of the universe. There are etchings in the stone and erected signposts that some of the luckiest drones feel they know. They obviously speak about how we are to be with each other, and how the universe operates. The stone folk are given the largest view once on the slab and can see as far as their sight can bring them. They understand how limited the ant hill folk and the grass folk are.

The thing in this metaphor is they all live on a single plot of land. If they were an ant hill in a desert, by a river, in the middle of a city, in a jungle, etc... they would be entirely different their beliefs. Everything they know is so local, so limited.

We are those ants. Any time, Alex says, "These are our options..." my thought is just... How is that possible?

I'm reminded of Tom Campbell and his "Big TOE" theories and wonder if maybe so much of what we see is so small compared to the experience of what the universe is. After all, Newtonian Physics is useful for one particular view. Great at analyzing cannonball trajectories but terrible at understanding Quantum string theory. Quantum physics works amazingly for the theoretical tiny particles but is lousy at describing the laws of motion.

Consider that there's truth in all these things, but not complete. Just as the materialists get glimmerings and the Gnostics, and the fundamentalists, and the atheists, etc...
Let me dogear this conversation with the understanding that my personal history is all about what we would say in Dungeons & Dragons circles as Neutral Good alignment. It wouldn't matter if it's through laws or through chaos, the ultimate good is part and parcel of my internal lodestone. I grew up loving King Arthur and the Round Table (I did my undergraduate thesis on this). My favourite superheroes growing up were Captain America (ironically he's the most Canadian superhero in my mind) and Superman (actually made by a Canadian surprisingly), Spider-man and Batman. Robin Hood and Captain Kirk.

Imagine if we step away from our ant metaphor but utilize it for a wider extended experience. Imagine if Tom Zinser (one of my favourite guests of Alex's) is right, the materialists are right, the Gnostics are right, Tom Campbell is right etc...
Zinser talks about darkness and the light. They are things without judgement. They simply are. But there is evil. Evil is certainly something that utilizes darkness or light for its own ends. Tom Campbell swears that it's all about growth or corruption.
What if what we consider "love" is just the emotional benefit of "growth". Just as pleasure is the by-product of sex which is from a biologist's perspective is for reproduction chiefly. Growth. Diversity.
The love we assume is what it's all about. But what if it's not that? What if love is what we feel in the process of "evolution" (that's our silly limited view of it) of understanding the greater spirit of which we are a part. An attempt in understanding the vagaries of experience of life in every possible iteration?
What if "evil" or the selfishness that it provides, the control, the demand for authoritarian and unitary thought is designed to draw energy away from the growth and therefore encourage entropy from the whole. The whole aspect that Alex talks about "do as thou wilt" from a Christian perspective is Lucifer's Fall. His desire to run things and be the authority.
All of these things and ideas and beliefs are hints of the whole. But the main focus is that what we "feel" could very well just be symptoms of what our ultimate purpose is. Maybe it has nothing to do with our definitions of "good" and "evil" but those are just very limited understandings of the grander plan of evolution as opposed to entropy.

Why are we stuck with very small options when we're just the ants?
 
Interesting. I have always believed that the punishment needs to be commensurate with the crime, but never considered the sort of situation you describe, where there is no larger justice system to implement things such as fines or jail time. However, I would still argue that excess punishment is still immoral, even if it prevents further crimes. My reasoning goes back to the classic trolley problem — the rationale behind utilitarianism. We cannot allow ourselves to be fooled by the numbers. Sacrificing fairness for the good of the many just puts the many under the rule of tyranny.
Man I love you J Randall. Thank you for allowing me opportunities to test my sensibilities. I hope I won't disappoint.

If you are an alpha responsible for a tribe of 80 (men/women/children), and in order to supply food for your camp you must temporarily share a border with hostile tribe, you will temporarily have less means available to apply fairness to any camp members having any erratic episodes which could place your tribe in jeopardy. For instance, someone says "F you! I'm gonna go tell the neighbor camp where you keep the gold" You may have to kill him knowing that the enemy tribe could do a lot more damage if they capture him as a hostage. And you can't afford to waste security efforts on watching/monitoring him or maybe even keeping him locked up.... Whereas, when there is no enemy sharing your border, you could totally lock him up and invest efforts in his rehabilitation.
Would you disagree that this premise adequately demonstrates that the rules' structure should always depend on the situation/those to whom they'll apply?
 
Man I love you J Randall. Thank you for allowing me opportunities to test my sensibilities. I hope I won't disappoint.

If you are an alpha responsible for a tribe of 80 (men/women/children), and in order to supply food for your camp you must temporarily share a border with hostile tribe, you will temporarily have less means available to apply fairness to any camp members having any erratic episodes which could place your tribe in jeopardy. For instance, someone says "F you! I'm gonna go tell the neighbor camp where you keep the gold" You may have to kill him knowing that the enemy tribe could do a lot more damage if they capture him as a hostage. And you can't afford to waste security efforts on watching/monitoring him or maybe even keeping him locked up.... Whereas, when there is no enemy sharing your border, you could totally lock him up and invest efforts in his rehabilitation.
Would you disagree that this premise adequately demonstrates that the rules' structure should always depend on the situation/those to whom they'll apply?

Thanks. I think the real thanks should go to Alex for providing the forum and allowing a variety of perspectives.

The short answer to your question would be: No, the rules' structure should not always depend on the situation, but judgement and sentencing should. In other words, exculpatory circumstances should be taken into consideration when determining a sentence, but the rulebook ( the structure ) itself should apply to everyone equally ( IMO ).
 
Last edited:
Thanks. I think the real thanks should go to Alex for providing the forum and allowing a variety of perspectives.

The short answer to your question would be: No, the rules' structure should not always depend on the situation, but judgement and sentencing should. In other words, exculpatory circumstances should be taken into consideration when determining a sentence, but the rulebook ( the structure ) itself should apply to everyone equally ( IMO ).
Agreed, and I stand corrected. I misappropriated my terms.
I meant to imply that drastic punishment is wrong insomuch as you can afford to do otherwise while still keeping safe those whose safety is your responsibility. As you stated, it's true that rules could be written to encompass universal morality for all the various situations. My rhetoric was geared toward to refute the idea that any particular act is always wrong or always right. So this leads to bandwidth. Which is why even with super computers we will probably always need to judges to interpret whether morality and circumstance are being accounted for when sentencing.
 
My rhetoric was geared toward to refute the idea that any particular act is always wrong or always right.

I think it's possible for some particular act to be always wrong or always right, provided that the context in each incident is the same. For example we might say that it's always wrong to cause unnecessary suffering, but that implies that sometimes, suffering might be necessary in order to achieve a greater good. Who decides whether that suffering is justified? So it seems to me that it's more often the case that particular acts are relatively better or relatively worse depending on the situation.

Can you think of any examples of moral absolutes – acts that don't depend on context in order to be morally evaluated? What about acting on good or evil intention? Is the outcome relevant to the moral value of the act? Personally, I don't think so. If we set out to do evil, we are committing an evil act. If we set out to do good, we are performing a good act. The success or failure of the endeavor doesn't change the intent. A foiled hero doesn't make them a villain any more than a foiled villain makes them a hero.
 
Last edited:
I think it's possible for some particular act to be always wrong or always right, provided that the context in each incident is the same. For example we might say that it's always wrong to cause unnecessary suffering, but that implies that sometimes, suffering might be necessary in order to achieve a greater good. Who decides whether that suffering is justified? So it seems to me that it's more often the case that particular acts are relatively better or relatively worse depending on the situation.

Can you think of any examples of moral absolutes – acts that don't depend on context in order to be morally evaluated? What about acting on good or evil intention? Is the outcome relevant to the moral value of the act? Personally, I don't think so. If we set out to do evil, we are committing an evil act. If we set out to do good, we are performing a good act. The success or failure of the endeavor doesn't change the intent. A foiled hero doesn't make them a villain any more than a foiled villain makes them a hero.
I agree with you again. And no, I've never been successful at defining any irrefutable absolutes.
To circle this back to the guest Cherylee and her reflections, I think the idea I'm trying to solidify is that of the expansion of the scale of the context used to quantify morality. She displayed the thing many NDE'ers do which I love so much, which is the sense that our context is incomplete. And they do it with such compassion, and lack of scarcity. And I always run up against this whenever I daydream about what I would do if I had a magic wand with which I could curse all the evil oligarchs and abusers of the world; I've never been able to justify a "correct" use of that magic wand - in light of the greater context. I think some people are here gaining soul experience in do-badding.
 
I had a dream about this exact subject years ago. Here it is, from my journal, dated 8/6/1990:

> [3:23 am] I am going to start w/ the last scene first, because it may be the most interesting. It concerns Adolf Hitler most specifically. I see him having recently died for at least the second time this century, w/ full military honors, in the person of a Russian military commander. His name began with the sound "enh"(first or last I do not know--probably first name + letter "N" in our alphabet). After dying as Hitler, he had come all the way to Russia, where he was duly born + had to undertake the difficulties of a new language (which he enjoyed). In fact, he seemed very happy to be able to have this chance to do good things. His tenure later in the Soviet military was not characterized by cruelty, though efficiency was one of his hallmarks. He was an officer of mid-rank. This was exactly where he wanted to be because he didn't want to have the opportunity or ability to cause the kind of harm he caused in his previous life.

He allowed some bad things to happen but would make an effort to mitigate the damage when he was in a position to do so. For instance, if he was asked to do something that would lead to 20 casualties, he would (if possible) modify the way he carried out the orders so that there were 17 casualties instead. He didn't seem conscious that he did those things for the reasons he did them. To everyone else, he just looked "practical". If 20 casualties cost the government 20,000 rubles but 17 casualties cost 10,000 rubles, he'd say they couldn't waste money on an operation that would send the same message whether 17 or 20 casualties.

I then see a Soviet funeral service. Immediately afterward, I see the image of an exploded building with Hitler's body somewhere inside. Standing along two sides of the path leading to this building are a great many people, formerly having been subjected to Hitler, now humorously paying homage to him [paying their respects]. They keep looking up and I see a shadow on the ground from above, so perhaps a plane?

When Hitler originally came into Russia, it was on foot in the snow and he wasn't aware of the passing of his physical body. He was in the house where he was found when he saw (as a ghost) Russian soldiers flood the building. He was afraid they would recognize him, so he made an effort to hide. He thought they didn't notice him. He reasoned this was because they hadn't looked closely at his uniform and thought he was one of them. In fact, they didn't see him at all. After playing cat and mouse while the soldiers searched the building, Hitler realized he could walk among them safely. He did this (in his mind) because they seemed to be looking everywhere else except within their midst. His fear of them was so great that he stayed with them, one soldier in particular.

The man Hitler attached himself to belonged to a group of Russian soldiers. When they returned to Russia from the front, Hitler went with them. He was surprised they allowed him to stay, and even more, that they didn't recognize him. Next, he was born into that one soldier's family and then later went into the Russian military himself.
Fascinating. And I'd like to build on the synchronistic theme as I've read it.

When I brought up Hitler it was a hyperbole / exaggerating to prove a point about the possibility that past and future lives might be interwoven with purpose. My belief is that "bad people" serve equally as crucially as "good people" in regard to this planet remaining a place where we learn how to love God/Universe/Higher-Purpose by faith and without evidence. When I described Hitler reincarnated as a porn shop janitor in west Hollywood, it was myself that I was picturing as the janitor (briefly thank goodness, only to form the description). I tried to imagine whether the janitor (me) would recognize that significance, but that's where I stopped imagining since that was enough nuance for me to write up the rest of what i was thinking (above).
But your story rung more synchronicity on top of that. When I was reading it, only a few sentences in, I automatically pictured You (or me) as the character in your dream playing out as Hitler's alternate reincarnation. Notice that your story didn't include any reference to the actual Hitler's life events, rather making it an archetype, no? Playing out the idea of: what would it be like if I had to wait until my next life to make good on my past?
Lastly, I landed on the idea (mainly because I don't currently subscribe to reincarnation theory) that this play-on-archetype could represent our chance to find redeeming opportunities in this life for us to embrace fully, as if in another life.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, but inconclusive. I have a video from an old series somewhere that is actually better than all of the ones I've seen on YouTube so far. I don't know that some sort of PSI is the causal agent for the effect produced. Maybe it is. Or maybe it's something else.

If PK was a thing, it should be far more self-evident across a far larger cross-section of the population. But instead, it's always in this gray area, as if whatever is behind the phenomenon wants us to question it without giving us definitive proof. This pattern also fits the UFO phenomenon, so I think it's fair to ask if the two are linked. What if the aliens like messing with our minds just to see what we'll make of it?

What if PSI is only limited to few individuals though? And is limited by our consensus reality of what we believe could happen? Throw in the placebo effect as another strange phenomenon to look at, and things get wierd!

I do get the links with whatever may be behind the UFO phenomenon though. A lot of the spooky stuff seems to have an element of doubt behind it, or "not quite there yet" type of understanding. Perpetual plausible deniability.
 
Interesting, but inconclusive.
You have to realise that all science is inconclusive.

Every experiment might be wrong. Repeating an experiment lowers the chance that it is wrong, but there is still a chance that both experiments are wrong. As more people confirm an experiment, subsequent people repeating the experiment may think twice before reporting that they failed. Some may even decide to adjust their results to make it look as if they succeeded....

Real proofs are only possible in mathematics.

David
 
You have to realise that all science is inconclusive.

Every experiment might be wrong. Repeating an experiment lowers the chance that it is wrong, but there is still a chance that both experiments are wrong. As more people confirm an experiment, subsequent people repeating the experiment may think twice before reporting that they failed. Some may even decide to adjust their results to make it look as if they succeeded....

Real proofs are only possible in mathematics.

David

Fair enough — depending on how you define "inconclusive" and "real proofs". Mathematical proofs are a form of logic, and logic extends beyond mathematics. So there can be logical proofs for non-mathematical problems.

When a logical proof is not possible, then we rely on the concept of reasonable doubt to draw conclusions. The weasel word in there is "reasonable". What exactly do we mean by that? I suppose it can mean different things to different people. Personally, when it comes to the paranormal, if there is a plausible mundane explanation, then I tend to go with that rather than jumping to conclusions.
 
Back
Top